Alan Dobbie

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

Hi Jeremy, appreciate your point, but there's a problem here. Strava show 1-second numeric precision, and use that for the leaderboards.  There's not much else they can do.  But those timings are n...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• Bearbeitet 5. November 2019 17:47
• 2 Stimmen

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

Nice idea @Liam, but unfortunately different devices (eg Garmin Edge versus generic smart-phone) have very different locational accrurcy and sampling intervals. Accuracy /versus precision. So where...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 1 Stimme

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

Vote with your feet. I'm not renewing my subscription @ £48/yr. With only 1 sec precision, and often worse than that accuracy, the way they handle the kom assignment in general is kind of nonsense ...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 3 Stimmen

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

@Eric, I agree, keep it simple. The recent discussion was to rationalise why it makes no sense to do anything other than treat all tied kom holders' the same, such as have it on all their profiles....

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 1 Stimme

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

Not sure about leaderboards being their bread and butter, but regardless whether timing inaccuracies of at least a second are from sampling frequency, or position error, the fact that mobile phones...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 1 Stimme

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

@Nate, unfortunately I'm pretty sure they cannot break it down to tenths of a second. Even on a Garmin, the sampling frequency isn't up to it, but certainly not on a mobile phone. Already if you lo...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 2 Stimmen

1. Community
2. New Feature Ideas
3. Automatic flagging feature for activities with suspicious data/wrong type selected

Frequent offenders is another pattern I've noticed, especially on the same segments. Some suggested weighting factors for auto-flagging rides (just indicators to be taken collectively):* Frequent o...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 9 Stimmen

1. Community
2. New Feature Ideas
3. Automatic flagging feature for activities with suspicious data/wrong type selected

Just flagged a ride, for bad GPS data, where the whole ride had a max of 45kmh, yet a 0.4km segment along the way took a kom at 84kmh. 84kmh on the flat. Come on, this shouldn't require manual inte...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 4 Stimmen

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

@Ellen, Your comment has me curious... In what way is the proposed system not "perfect", at least c/w the existing system? In my understanding, the only change proposed is to the stats shown on a u...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 3 Stimmen

1. Community
2. Feature Discussion
3. All tied KOMs/QOMs/CRs should count and register on Profiles

Having got more ties recently, I raised this directly with Strava too. They understood, they just don't really care. "...currently no plans to fix this are in the works." No additional users or rev...

• Kommentar anzeigen
• 7 Stimmen